A 2,000-step increase—about one mile—was linked to a 25% to 50% drop in the risk of dying from any cause among people who were mostly inactive. That finding sits at the heart of a new review suggesting that movement and fitness may predict longevity more strongly than diet quality alone.

Glenn Gaesser, a professor at Arizona State University’s College of Health Solutions, and Robert Sallis, a family and sports medicine doctor at Kaiser Permanente, compared decades of research on diet, physical activity and cardiorespiratory fitness. Their analysis, published in Mayo Clinic Proceedings, is described as the first head-to-head comparison of how diet quality and activity relate to mortality. The researchers searched PubMed for reviews that combine study results and for long-term studies that follow groups of people. They set no date limit, though most of the data came from the past 10 to 20 years.

Across the studies they reviewed, physical activity and fitness had a stronger link with lower all-cause mortality—the risk of death from any cause—than diet quality did. For people with the lowest diet quality, or the highest intake of foods such as ultraprocessed products, red and processed meat, sugary foods and drinks, and fried foods, the increased risk was 3% to 20%. For people who did not exercise and sat for most of the day, the increase was 46% to more than 163%.

The researchers also examined step counts. People who averaged 11,000 to 16,000 steps a day had a 45% to 67% lower mortality risk than those averaging roughly 2,000 to 5,000 steps. Gaesser said the intensity of exercise seemed less important than simply accumulating steps. In comparisons that considered diet and activity together, high activity or fitness appeared to largely remove the extra risk linked with a lower-quality diet.

That does not mean food choices do not matter. Raising fruit, vegetable, whole-grain and fiber intake from current levels to amounts recommended by U.S. dietary guidelines was associated with a 6% to 20% lower risk. Gaesser said the findings instead challenge a public-health focus that gives diet far more attention than activity, when the comparative evidence points to a stronger relationship between movement and longevity.

Some short-term studies in the review tested adults who ate a range of unhealthy foods for one or two weeks while exercising daily or keeping their steps between 11,000 and 12,000. Those studies found no adverse health effects during that period. The researchers cautioned that this does not make an unhealthy diet harmless over the long term; the finding shows how activity may affect health measures in the short term, not that it cancels every consequence of poor eating.

Sallis said the goal is not only to add years, but to have better years. He noted that a healthy body mass index, or BMI, does not always mean someone is healthy, while regular exercise and fitness are often seen alongside better health. The practical message is straightforward: build more movement into the day, even in small increments, while continuing to make nutritious food choices. More attention to both habits could help people focus not just on how long they live, but on how well.